Raptors at Feeders

Hawks Eat Smaller Birds to the Dismay of Feeder Providers

Dec 23, 2008 Albert Burchsted

People who feed birds are upset to find hawks using bird feeders to capture prey. Birds at feeders are as important to the hawks as the seeds are to the smaller birds.

The increase in bird feeding throughout the year across the United States and Canada has resulted in larger numbers of normally migratory birds remaining in the north during the winter and a northward range expansion of several one-time southern birds such as the northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) and the northern mockingbird (Mimus polyglottis) . Many of these birds are able to switch between an insectivorous diet during the summer months and a seed-eating diet during the winter. Black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus), tufted titmouse (Parus bicolor), American goldfinches (Carduelis tristis), red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus), red-bellied woodpeckers (Melanerpes carolinus), and many others benefit from the warmheartedness of their human neighbors. In return, these birds give us many pleasurable hours of observation and provide the careful watcher insight as to their social behaviors.

A Not-so-Beneficial Effect of Bird Feeders

Often a watcher will see a crow-sized bird hunched over on a tree branch near the feeder. The bird may be observed pulling at a lump it holds down, scattering feathers to the wind. Cooper's hawks (Accipiter cooperii.) and the smaller sharp-shinned hawks (A. striatus) often feed in this manner. When observers attempt to get close enough to observe the prey, these hawk will grasp their prey in the talons of one foot and fly away from the intruder.

What Do the Hawks Eat?

Preferred prey are the common feeder birds: mourning doves (Zenaida macroura), northern cardinals, mockingbirds, pigeons (Columba livia), sparrows, chickadees, and titmice. The hawks capture the birds at or on their way to a neighborhood feeding station and carry them off to nearby trees. As a mourning dove is about one quarter the hawk's size, the dove would make a substantial contribution to a Cooper's hawk's daily energy needs, and even the smaller sparrows and chickadees help to keep the hawk alive.

Hawks at Bird Feeders

Birders note that when there is a hawk in the neighborhood, many smaller birds disappear and nearby feeders are avoided for a while. On first arriving at a feeding station, a Cooper's or the smaller sharp-shinned hawk, A. striatus, may take three or four birds in quick succession. The smaller birds rapidly become wary forcing the hawk to locate a nearby hiding place from which to dart from ambush to capture more prey. Usually the hawks only visit a feeding station for a short period of time each day and take but a bird or two. If a feeding station is especially busy or there is an exceptionally good hiding place nearby, the hawk may continue to visit for one or two weeks, but eventually the prey birds stay away, and the hawk moves on to find another location.

Click here to learn ways to discourage hawks from attacking birds.

Cooper's Hawks Hunt Late in the Day

Both hawk species burst out of dense foliage during the day, scattering and sometimes capturing smaller birds at feeders. They take advantage of the need for birds to find food regularly on short winter days.

In the northeast, evening falls shortly after 4 PM in the winter. Diurnal (day active) birds become less cautious as the day ends because they have only a short time left to find food and consume it. In addition to hunting at feeders, Cooper's hawks focus on intercepting unwary birds making their way to overnight refuges, often capturing prey after the sun sets. When successful, one will continue to feed well after dark.

Defensive Behavior of Prey

Some birds mob (harass) and scold these hawks. This behavior seems to bring other birds' attention to the predator, helping them locate it, and reducing the hawk's ability to capture prey unaware. Blue jays (Cyanocitta cristata ) and American crows (Corvus brachyrhynchos) mob hawks and owls all year long; while mockingbirds, red-winged blackbirds, and common grackles (Quiscalus quiscula) primarily mob these birds during the breeding season. During these short winter days, however, most birds merely leave the area when a hawk moves in.

Birders and Hawks

People that feed birds have mixed feelings about these small hawks: Some people despise them for killing “their” birds, others realize that hawks have to make a living like other animals do. What is intriguing is that some people who become angry about hawks taking feeder birds find nothing wrong with letting their pet kitty out of doors to wreak mayhem, or to feed feral cats which in sum kill hundreds of millions of birds each year. At least the hawks eat what they kill. But to some feeders of birds, the hawks' habit of eating in the open is quite unsettling.

The copyright of the article Raptors at Feeders in Birds is owned by Albert Burchsted. Permission to republish Raptors at Feeders in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
Juvenile Cooper's Hawk, Albert Burchsted Juvenile Cooper's Hawk
   
What do you think about this article?

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
post your comment
What is 10+2?

Comments

Jan 3, 2009 9:45 AM
Guest :

We are seeing a big increase of hawks each year in our SW Charlotte, NC area. A neighbor was on her way back to work after lunch a few weeks ago, saw a hawk with a small bird, got out of her car and fought the hawk off, picked up the bird, got in her car and drove off with it in hand. She drove a few miles and stopped to release the bird. As soon as she set the bird down the hawk who had been following her swooped down and snatched the bird up, flew away to her shock.
We just witnessed a hawk with a mourning dove in its claws fly away as I opened the patio door. That sight just ruined my day so I came online to see what others are saying on this issue. These are no baby hawks. One hovering around here has to be all of two feet long.
Jan 7, 2009 9:50 PM
Guest :
I'm currently dealing with hawks around the area. There's a Cooper's Hawk and a Sharp-shinned Hawk, both of whom sit on an antenna at an apartment building close by. The hawks have claimed two "victims" so far, both sparrows. While the hawks are magnificent to see, I have a lot of "regulars" who come to my feeders (a cardinal and his wife, a family of blue jays, and even squirrels who I feed in a separate area in my yard) and I'd hate to see them become a hawk's dinner. But I realize that the hawks are just doing what comes naturally to them. I will not stop putting my feeders out. There are so many birds who eat at my feeders, and food is scarce this time of the year.
Jan 21, 2009 2:31 PM
Guest :
I am in rural northwestern Ohio and have a hawk that has found my feeding area. It comes right up onto my back porch where there is a sliding glass door. It has gotten several small birds, and based on their behavior, the rest of the small birds are being very cautious about visiting my feeders. Hoping that in a few weeks the hawk will find its meals elsewhere so my little birds come back!
Jan 23, 2009 7:05 AM
Guest :
I am in northern NJ and have several feeders in my backyard. My yard is also behind a "greenfield" area which is wooded and protected. I normally have many birds but lately there are no birds at the feeder which is unusual because it is very cold and the ground is snow covered. I asked my local wild birds unlimited store owner and he said thee was most probably a raptor about. Sure enough, late in the afternoon I saw him flying overhead. I had also seen one this summer picking at a small bird under his talons right on my patio adirondack chair. I was very distressed, but like the poster below, I know this behavior comes naturally and I need to respect it. I just hope that he will soon lose interest in my area because there are fewer birds and move on.
Jan 23, 2009 4:00 PM
Guest :
I am in northern NJ and have several feeders in my backyard. My yard is also behind a "greenfield" area which is wooded and protected. I normally have many birds but lately there are no birds at the feeder which is unusual because it is very cold and the ground is snow covered. I asked my local wild birds unlimited store owner and he said thee was most probably a raptor about. Sure enough, late in the afternoon I saw him flying overhead. I had also seen one this summer picking at a small bird under his talons right on my patio adirondack chair. I was very distressed, but like the poster below, I know this behavior comes naturally and I need to respect it. I just hope that he will soon lose interest in my area because there are fewer birds and move on.
May 19, 2009 11:42 AM
Guest :
I think it's great that hawk's are learning to adapt to more urban settings, like small birds have for decades. Sure I'm sad when I see that one has captured a threatened species but it's nature. How is it any different than birds eating insects or cats eating mice.
6 Comments